7 Best Ear Sealants For Open Water For Swimmers

Nothing ruins a perfect open water swim faster than the sharp, throbbing ache of "swimmer’s ear" after you’ve finally reached the shore. Whether you are battling choppy lake waves or salty ocean currents, keeping your ear canals dry is essential for long-term health and comfort. These seven ear sealants and plugs are your best defense against the elements, ensuring you stay in the water longer without the risk of infection.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Understanding Ear Protection for Open Water

Open water swimming presents a unique set of challenges compared to the controlled environment of a chlorinated pool. In lakes and oceans, the water is often teeming with bacteria, debris, and fluctuating temperatures that can easily irritate the delicate lining of the ear canal. Once moisture gets trapped behind a wall of wax, it creates the perfect breeding ground for painful infections.

Effective ear protection isn’t just about blocking water; it’s about maintaining a reliable seal while allowing for enough comfort to focus on your stroke. You must balance the need for a watertight barrier with the ability to hear your surroundings, such as boat traffic or fellow swimmers. Investing in the right gear is the difference between a refreshing workout and a week spent in the doctor’s office.

Mack’s Pillow Soft Silicone Earplugs Selection

If you prioritize simplicity and a universal fit, Mack’s Pillow Soft silicone putty is the gold standard. Because they are moldable, they conform to the unique contours of your outer ear rather than being shoved into the canal, which significantly reduces pressure. They are incredibly easy to apply and remove, making them a favorite for beginners who struggle with the "suction" feeling of traditional plugs.

However, keep in mind that putty plugs can sometimes lose their tackiness if you have long hair that gets caught in the seal. They are best suited for casual swimmers or those who want a low-cost, reliable solution that doesn’t require a custom fitting. If you want a no-fuss, effective barrier that just works, these are your go-to.

Blue Tack Reusable Putty for Custom Ear Seals

Blue Tack is a fantastic alternative for swimmers who find standard pre-molded plugs uncomfortable or ineffective. Because you can control the exact amount of material used, you can create a custom seal that perfectly bridges the gap of your concha. This allows for a more personalized fit that stays put even during more vigorous swimming sessions.

This product is ideal for swimmers with oddly shaped ear canals who find that store-bought sizes never quite seal correctly. Just remember that hygiene is key; since these are reusable, you must clean them thoroughly after every swim to prevent bacteria buildup. If you are willing to spend a few seconds molding them before you hit the water, the comfort level is unmatched.

Doc’s Proplugs Vented Earplugs for Swimmers

Doc’s Proplugs stand out because they feature a tiny vent, which is a game-changer for maintaining equilibrium and hearing. Unlike solid plugs that can make you feel isolated or dizzy, these allow a small amount of pressure equalization while still keeping the bulk of the water out. This makes them a top choice for serious triathletes and those who spend extended time in rougher water.

They come in various sizes, so you will need to measure your ear to get the right fit, but the payoff is a professional-grade seal. They are durable, long-lasting, and provide a level of security that putty simply cannot match in high-impact waves. If you take your open water training seriously, these are worth the investment.

Ear Band-It Ultra Swimming Headband Features

Sometimes, the best way to keep water out of your ears is to add a secondary layer of defense. The Ear Band-It Ultra is a neoprene headband designed to be worn over your earplugs to keep them firmly in place. This is the ultimate "fail-safe" for swimmers who frequently have their plugs dislodged by heavy surf or aggressive flip turns.

The Ultra version features a reinforced grip lining that prevents the band from slipping off your head, even when wet. It is highly recommended for children or anyone who has had bad luck with plugs falling out mid-swim. If you want total peace of mind, pairing this band with a set of silicone plugs is the most secure setup you can find.

SurfEars 3.0 Earplugs for Water Clarity

SurfEars 3.0 are engineered specifically for those who need to keep water out but refuse to lose their connection to the environment. Their unique design allows sound to travel through while blocking water, which is a massive advantage when you need to maintain spatial awareness. They come with various sizes of silicone tips to ensure a snug, watertight fit for almost any ear shape.

These are particularly great for surfers and open water swimmers who navigate busy waterways where hearing approaching waves or other athletes is vital. While they are a bit pricier than basic putty, the acoustic clarity they provide is worth every penny. If you feel claustrophobic wearing standard earplugs, SurfEars 3.0 will change your entire experience.

Putty Buddies Floating Silicone Earplugs

Putty Buddies are essentially the "adventure-ready" version of standard silicone earplugs. They are formulated to be extra soft, which makes them very comfortable for long-distance swims, and they are designed to float if they happen to fall out. This is a massive benefit if you are swimming in deep water and don’t want to lose your gear to the bottom of the lake.

They are bright and easy to spot, making them a practical choice for open water sessions where visibility matters. While they may not provide the extreme-duty seal of a professional vented plug, they are perfect for recreational swimmers who want comfort and safety. You really can’t go wrong with these if you’re looking for a reliable, entry-level option.

Ohropax Silicone Earplugs for Cold Water

When you are swimming in colder temperatures, standard wax or putty can sometimes become brittle or lose its seal. Ohropax silicone plugs are known for their high-quality, pliable material that maintains its consistency even in chilly water. They provide a dense, reliable barrier that effectively blocks out the cold water that often triggers ear canal spasms.

These are the ideal choice for cold-water enthusiasts who need a plug that won’t harden or fail when the temperature drops. They are comfortable enough for long sessions and offer a very high level of water exclusion. If you find yourself shivering after a swim because of cold water hitting your inner ear, these are the solution you need.

Proper Insertion and Maintenance Techniques

Even the best earplugs will fail if they aren’t inserted correctly or maintained with care. Always ensure your ear canal is free of excess moisture before applying your sealants; a dry ear is a sealed ear. For putty or silicone, warm the material in your hands first to make it pliable, then gently press it over the opening of the ear—never jam it deep into the canal.

After your swim, rinse your plugs with fresh water and mild soap to remove salt, sand, and skin oils. Store them in a clean, ventilated case to prevent mold or bacterial growth. Treating your gear with respect will extend its life and, more importantly, protect your ears from unnecessary irritation.

Minimizing Ear Infections in Open Water

Prevention is always better than cure, and that starts with your post-swim routine. As soon as you exit the water, tilt your head to the side to help gravity drain any trapped droplets, and gently dry the outer ear with a soft towel. Many swimmers also use a simple mixture of rubbing alcohol and white vinegar to help dry out the canal and prevent bacterial growth.

Never use cotton swabs to dry your ears, as they can push debris deeper or cause micro-abrasions that invite infection. By combining high-quality ear protection with consistent post-swim hygiene, you can enjoy the open water for years to come. Stay vigilant, stay dry, and keep swimming.

Choosing the right ear protection is a personal journey of finding what fits your anatomy and your specific swimming environment. Whether you opt for the acoustic clarity of SurfEars or the reliable security of a headband, the most important thing is that you find a system you will actually use every single time. Protect your ears now, and you’ll ensure that many more seasons of open water adventure remain on your horizon.