10 Essential Supplies for a Backyard Pool Treasure Hunt

On a blistering hot summer afternoon, there is nothing quite like transforming a standard backyard pool into a high-stakes undersea adventure to keep energetic swimmers engaged. Running a successful pool treasure hunt requires more than just throwing random loose change into the deep end and hoping for the best. Having the right specialized gear turns a potentially chaotic splash-fest into a structured, safe, and wildly entertaining game that kids and adults will want to play weekend after weekend.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

How to Set Up a Safe and Fun Pool Treasure Hunt

Designing an engaging pool treasure hunt starts with a solid game plan and a bit of imagination. Begin by establishing a clear storyline, such as a sunken pirate galleon or an underwater space mission, to capture the players’ interest right from the start. Divide the pool into distinct zones based on swimming ability, keeping younger non-swimmers in the shallow end while reserving deep-water challenges for strong swimmers who can confidently touch the bottom.

To keep the game balanced, scatter a diverse mix of sinking targets and floating markers across the water. A good hunt shouldn’t just be a frantic race; instead, incorporate clues that players must decipher or a checklist of specific items they must retrieve in a particular order. Setting a reasonable time limit for each round keeps the energy high, prevents physical exhaustion, and allows everyone a fair chance to catch their breath between heats.

Before tossing any gear into the water, ensure your pool is properly prepped for heavy activity. Run your pool filter a few hours prior to game time to maximize water clarity, allowing divers to spot targets easily without straining their eyes. Clear away any bulky lounge chairs or pool toys from the immediate perimeter of the deck to prevent accidental trips and falls during the excitement of the hunt.

Sinking Dive Toys – SwimWays Toypedo Bandits

Sinking targets form the absolute core of any underwater treasure hunt. They force swimmers to submerge, open their eyes underwater, and practice breath control in a fun, active way. Without reliable sinking toys, a treasure hunt lacks the vertical dimension that makes underwater games so uniquely challenging.

SwimWays Toypedo Bandits are the ideal pick for this task because of their hydrodynamic design. Unlike basic dive sticks that drop straight down, these mini-torpedoes glide up to 20 feet through the water when thrown. This gliding action scatters them randomly across the pool floor, making the search much more dynamic and unpredictable for eager divers.

• Length: 5 inches
• Pack Size: 4 brightly colored bandits per pack
• Recommended Age: 5 years and up

Because these toys are made of hard, heavy plastic, they sink quickly and can impact the pool floor with some force. Swimmers should wait until the bandits have fully settled on the bottom before diving to avoid getting hit. These toys are perfect for confident swimmers who love a fast-paced challenge, but they are not suitable for toddlers who cannot yet swim down to retrieve items from the bottom.

Floating Basket – SwimWays Spring Float Caddy

Every successful treasure hunt requires a central “treasure chest” where players can deposit their hard-earned loot. A floating basket keeps the game centered directly in the water, eliminating the need for wet swimmers to constantly run back and forth onto a slippery pool deck. It also serves as a visible boundary marker or a home base during team-based games.

The SwimWays Spring Float Caddy stands out because of its patented inner-spring technology, which keeps the inflatable outer ring incredibly stable even in highly agitated water. The deep mesh basket allows water to drain instantly, ensuring the gathered treasure doesn’t make the caddy heavy or prone to capsizing. Built-in cup holders can also double as slots to hold dry game clues or small tokens.

• Material: Fabric-covered inflatable ring with a durable mesh center
• Portability: Folds flat into a compact circle for easy transport and storage
• Features: 2 cup holders and a spacious main compartment

While the fabric cover protects the inflatable bladder from punctures, it does require thorough rinsing with fresh water and air-drying before storage to prevent mold and mildew. This floating caddy is an excellent tool for keeping multi-item hunts organized and contained. It is not designed to support human weight, so players must be instructed not to climb on or hang from the caddy during play.

Swim Goggles – Speedo Vanquisher 2.0 Mirrored

You cannot retrieve treasure if you cannot see it through a blur of water and chlorine. Quality swim goggles protect sensitive eyes from irritation, allowing searchers to keep their eyes wide open to track down well-hidden items on the pool floor. They are a non-negotiable piece of gear for safety, comfort, and performance during any underwater game.

The Speedo Vanquisher 2.0 Mirrored goggles are a premier choice due to their wide peripheral lens design and snug, leak-free silicone seals. The mirrored coating is particularly useful for backyard pools, as it cuts down on harsh surface glare on sunny days, helping swimmers spot sinking toys from the surface. Their low-profile design also ensures they stay firmly on the face during high-energy dives.

• Lens Type: Mirrored, anti-fog coated polycarbonate
• Strap: Double silicone head strap with an adjustable secure clip
• Fit: Low-profile inner eye fit with 4 interchangeable nosepieces

The anti-fog coating inside the lenses is delicate; wiping the inside of the goggles with a towel or finger will ruin the treatment. To maintain them, simply rinse them in clean, fresh water after each pool session and let them air dry. These goggles are perfect for older children, teens, and adults who want crystal-clear underwater vision, but they may be too small or technical for very young children who prefer wide-view swim masks.

Waterproof Notepad – Rite in the Rain Notebook

A truly memorable treasure hunt involves clues, riddles, or a checklist of items that players must find in order. Using standard paper near a pool is a recipe for disaster, as it will disintegrate into wet pulp within seconds, potentially clogging your pool’s filtration system. A waterproof notepad allows the game master to write down clues that can survive splashes, wet hands, and even total immersion.

The Rite in the Rain Notebook utilizes a unique, wood-based patented paper designed specifically to shed water, sweat, and grease. The binding and pages are tough enough to survive being dropped directly into the pool, allowing you to leave submerged clues on the steps or taped to the pool wall. It keeps the game structured and prevents arguments over which items have already been found.

• Size: 3″ x 5″ top-spiral pocket notebook
• Page Count: 100 pages (50 sheets) with a universal grid pattern
• Paper Type: Recyclable, all-weather archival-grade paper

To write on this paper when wet, you must use a standard graphite pencil, a crayon, or a specialized all-weather pen; standard gel pens and water-based markers will smear or wash off instantly. This notebook is a fantastic utility for parents or camp counselors organizing complex, clue-based pool games. It is unnecessary if your treasure hunt is a simple, non-structured “dive and grab” race.

Dive Rings – Melissa & Doug Sunny Patch Rings

While hydrodynamic toys are great for fast-moving games, upright dive rings are essential for younger or developing swimmers. Standard flat toys can be difficult for small hands to scrape off a vinyl pool liner. Weighted rings that stand upright on the pool floor offer an easy, accessible target for kids practicing their underwater grip.

Melissa & Doug Sunny Patch Rings feature a clever, weighted-foot design that keeps the cheerful sea-creature rings standing vertically on the pool bottom. The bright, high-contrast colors make them incredibly easy to spot through the water column. Made from soft, flexible plastic, they are easy to grab and gentle on delicate fingers and toes.

• Set Size: 6 uniquely designed sea-character rings
• Material: Flexible, heavy-duty, non-toxic plastic
• Design: Weighted bottom keeps rings standing upright

Over time, prolonged exposure to direct sunlight and harsh pool chemicals can cause the bright colors to fade and the plastic to degrade. To prolong their lifespan, store them in a shaded deck box when the game is over rather than leaving them floating in the pool. These rings are perfect for beginner to intermediate swimmers, but they do not offer enough of a physical challenge for older, advanced divers.

Foam Pool Noodle – Robelle Premium Pool Noodle

Pool noodles are incredibly versatile tools during a backyard water game. They can be bent into arches to create underwater swim-through obstacles, used as floating boundaries to mark off safe play zones, or given to weaker swimmers as temporary flotation support. Cheap, hollow foam noodles crumble quickly under heavy use, leaving messy foam debris in your skimmer basket.

The Robelle Premium Pool Noodle is constructed from heavy-duty, closed-cell foam coated with a protective vinyl layer. This vinyl coating resists tears, UV damage, and chlorine degradation, allowing it to survive seasons of rough play without falling apart. Its solid-core construction provides superior buoyancy that easily supports older kids and adults during active games.

• Dimensions: Approximately 46 inches long by 5.5 inches wide
• Material: Vinyl-coated, solid closed-cell foam
• Texture: Ribbed surface texture for a secure grip

This noodle is significantly thicker and stiffer than standard dollar-store pool noodles, which makes it highly durable but also harder to bend into tight shapes. Because of its density, it requires a larger storage footprint and cannot be easily compressed. This is the right choice for pool owners who want a long-lasting, heavy-duty game obstacle and are tired of replacing cheap foam toys every year.

Pool Skimmer Net – Swimline Heavy Duty Skimmer

A clean pool is a safe pool, especially when swimmers are diving to the bottom to search for small targets. A pool skimmer net is essential before the game starts to clear out floating leaves, bugs, and debris that can block visibility. During the hunt, the net also serves as a quick way for the game referee to scoop up floating clues or stray toys without getting wet.

The Swimline Heavy Duty Skimmer features a rugged, reinforced plastic frame that resists bending when pushed through heavy water. Its fine mesh netting is tight enough to trap tiny debris, while the curved front edge is designed to easily scoop items off the pool floor without scratching vinyl liners or plaster finishes.

• Frame Material: Reinforced ABS plastic
• Netting Type: Fine mesh screen for small debris capture
• Compatibility: Fits most standard 1-1/4″ telescopic pool poles

This product does not include the telescopic pole, which must be purchased separately to reach the center of larger pools. While the frame is exceptionally strong, scooping up highly water-logged, heavy items like soaked clothes or large piles of wet leaves can snap the neck if lifted incorrectly. It is an indispensable utility tool for pool maintenance that doubles as a handy game-management accessory.

Waterproof Stopwatch – Champion Sports Classic

Adding a timing element completely changes the dynamic of a pool treasure hunt. A stopwatch allows you to run structured time trials, track individual progress, and ensure that competitive swimmers aren’t holding their breath underwater for dangerously long intervals. It brings structure, fairness, and a sense of athletic competition to the game.

The Champion Sports Classic stopwatch is water-resistant, shock-resistant, and built to withstand the wet, high-impact environment of a pool deck. It features a large, clear digital display that is easy to read at a glance, even with water droplets on the screen. The tactile buttons provide a reassuring click, ensuring precise start and stop times when running split-second races.

• Display: Large LCD showing minutes, seconds, and hundredths of a second
• Water Resistance: Splash-proof and weather-resistant construction
• Accessories: Heavy-duty nylon neck lanyard included

While this stopwatch is highly water-resistant and handles wet hands and heavy splashes easily, it is not designed to be submerged in deep water for extended periods. It is perfect for coaches, parents, and refereeing game masters who want to keep the game moving on a schedule. Those looking for advanced features like swim stroke counters or lap-syncing apps should look to high-end smartwatches instead.

Floating Pool Lights – LOFTEK LED Color Lights

When the sun goes down, you don’t have to end the game. Nighttime treasure hunts add a thrilling layer of mystery to the backyard pool, turning the dark water into a glowing, colorful arena. Floating pool lights can be used as glowing “mines” to avoid, illuminated target zones, or underwater treasures that players must dive to collect.

LOFTEK LED Color Lights are fully waterproof, dustproof, and designed to float seamlessly on the water’s surface. They are made from a durable, toy-grade acrylic shell that can handle being kicked, splashed, and tossed around by active players. With a wireless remote, the game master can change colors or set the lights to flash to signal different stages of the treasure hunt.

• Power Source: Rechargeable battery (provides up to 10–12 hours of light)
• Control: Wireless remote with 16 color options and 4 dynamic modes
• Waterproof Rating: IP68 fully submersible rating

To maintain the waterproof seal, you must ensure that the charging port cap is screwed on completely straight and tight before placing the lights in the water. These lights are fantastic for evening pool parties and adding visual flair to night games, but they do require pre-planning to ensure the internal batteries are fully charged before the sun sets.

Resin Deck Box – Keter City 30 Gallon Box

Once the treasure hunt is finished, leaving wet toys, goggles, and noodles scattered across the grass or deck creates a serious tripping hazard and ruins your lawn. Outdoor pool gear left in the sun will quickly degrade from UV rays and heat. A dedicated resin deck box provides a secure, ventilated space to dry and store all your game supplies in one place.

The Keter City 30 Gallon Box is built from heavy-duty, weather-resistant polypropylene resin that will not rust, dent, peel, or fade in the sun. Its wood-look texture blends naturally into any outdoor patio or pool deck layout. The box keeps the interior dry and well-ventilated, allowing wet pool toys to dry safely without trapped moisture causing odor issues.

• Storage Capacity: 30 gallons (ideal for mid-sized toy collections)
• Material: Heavy-duty, weather-resistant resin plastic
• External Dimensions: 22.7″ W x 17.3″ D x 21.7″ H

This deck box requires quick, tool-free assembly upon arrival, which typically takes less than ten minutes. While it is perfect for storing dive rings, goggles, stopwatches, and smaller pool toys, it is not long enough to accommodate rigid, full-length pool noodles or oversized inflatable rafts. It is ideal for pool owners who want to keep their deck looking clean, organized, and professional between weekend pool parties.

Essential Pool Safety Rules to Establish First

No pool game is successful unless everyone makes it back to the deck safely. Before a single treasure is tossed into the water, gather all players and establish a strict no running policy on the wet pool deck. Slips on slick concrete or tile are the most common cause of backyard pool injuries and can quickly turn a fun afternoon into an emergency.

Designate at least one sober, responsible adult as the dedicated water watcher whose sole responsibility is to keep eyes on the pool. This person must not be distracted by phones, grilling, or conversations; their only job is to monitor the swimmers. Implement a rigid buddy system where every player is paired with a partner, ensuring that no one is diving or swimming alone without someone else actively watching their progress.

Finally, educate all participants on the dangers of shallow-water blackout, which can occur when players hyperventilate or hold their breath for too long in a competitive effort to stay submerged. Prohibit any games that encourage breath-holding endurance contests. Encourage players to take normal, relaxed breaths and to surface immediately if they feel any discomfort or fatigue while searching for treasure.

Equipping your backyard pool with high-quality, durable gear ensures your summer games are both thrilling and safe. By setting clear boundaries, using highly visible sinking and floating targets, and keeping safety as the top priority, you can create a backyard tradition that swimmers of all ages will look forward to every season. Set up your boundary lines, organize your clues, and let the adventure begin.