7 Common Pool Surface Problems and Solutions That Save Thousands

Your swimming pool’s surface isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s crucial for water quality, safety, and the overall longevity of your investment. Even with regular maintenance, pool surfaces inevitably develop issues that can quickly escalate from minor annoyances to costly repairs if left untreated.

From unsightly staining and stubborn algae growth to more serious structural concerns like cracks and etching, identifying common pool surface problems early is half the battle. The good news? Most issues have straightforward solutions that you can implement yourself or with professional help, saving you time and money in the long run.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

1. Scaling and Calcium Deposits: The White Menace

Scaling and calcium deposits are among the most common issues pool owners face, appearing as chalky white residue that clings stubbornly to your pool’s surface and equipment.

Identifying Calcium Buildup on Pool Surfaces

You’ll recognize calcium scaling as rough, crusty white deposits that form along the waterline, on steps, or across the entire pool surface. These deposits feel sharp to the touch and can’t be easily wiped away. As water evaporates, calcium and other minerals become more concentrated, especially in areas with hard water or high pH levels. If you notice white flaky patches that become increasingly rough over time, you’re dealing with calcium buildup.

Effective Solutions for Removing and Preventing Scale

For existing scale, use a pumice stone or scale removal product specifically formulated for your pool’s surface type. Lower your pool’s pH to 7.2-7.6 and maintain calcium hardness between 200-400 ppm for plaster pools and 175-225 ppm for vinyl or fiberglass. Regular brushing of pool walls and adding a scale inhibitor to your maintenance routine will prevent future buildup. For severe cases, consider acid washing but consult a professional first to avoid damaging your pool surface.

2. Etching: When Your Pool Surface Deteriorates

Common Causes of Pool Surface Etching

Etching occurs when acidic water dissolves the cement in plaster surfaces, creating rough, pitted areas. Low pH levels below 7.2 are the primary culprit, often resulting from improper chemical balance or over-shocking your pool. Automatic chlorinators that malfunction can continuously add acid, while rainwater runoff may introduce acidic substances. Heat accelerates this chemical reaction, making surfaces more vulnerable during hot summer months.

Restoration and Prevention Strategies for Etched Surfaces

For minor etching, acid washing followed by professional resurfacing can restore your pool’s smooth finish. Prevent future deterioration by maintaining pH between 7.4-7.6 and alkalinity at 80-120 ppm with weekly testing. Install automated pH controllers to monitor levels continuously, especially with salt systems. Add chemical adjustments slowly rather than all at once, and consider using cyanuric acid to stabilize chlorine. For severe cases, consult with pool renovation specialists about applying protective sealants during resurfacing.

3. Discoloration: Why Your Pool Surface Changed Color

Nothing’s more disappointing than noticing your once-pristine pool has developed unsightly discoloration. These color changes aren’t just cosmetic concerns—they often signal underlying chemical imbalances or maintenance issues that need addressing.

Types of Pool Surface Stains and Their Sources

Pool stains typically fall into three categories: organic, metal-based, and chemical. Organic stains appear as green, brown, or black spots from leaves, algae, or berries. Metal stains show up as rust (red/brown), copper (blue/green), or manganese (purple/black) discoloration. Chemical stains result from improper chlorine use or pH imbalances, creating bleached areas or yellow patches on your pool’s surface.

Treatment Options for Various Discoloration Issues

For organic stains, shock treatment with chlorine and algaecide often resolves the issue. Metal stains require specialized metal sequestrants or stain removers containing ascorbic acid. For severe discoloration, use vitamin C tablets directly on the stain or apply a commercial stain remover. Chemical stains typically need pH balancing and may require acid washing for stubborn cases. Always test treatments in a small area before full application.

4. Cracking and Structural Damage: Beyond Surface Level

Cracks and structural damage represent some of the most serious pool issues, potentially compromising the entire structure’s integrity if left unaddressed. Unlike cosmetic problems, these defects can lead to water loss, further deterioration, and expensive repairs.

Diagnosing Different Types of Pool Surface Cracks

Hairline cracks typically appear as thin lines under 1/8 inch wide and are usually cosmetic concerns rather than structural threats. Structural cracks, measuring 1/8 inch or wider, often indicate foundation settlement or ground movement. Spider cracks resemble a web pattern and commonly occur in plaster pools due to improper curing or shrinkage. Check for expanding cracks or those that leak water, as these signal more serious underlying issues.

Repair Methods and When to Call a Professional

Minor hairline cracks can be repaired with epoxy or polyurethane sealants designed specifically for underwater applications. Structural cracks require professional assessment and often involve draining the pool, applying reinforced patching compounds, and possibly addressing soil issues. Call a licensed pool contractor immediately for cracks wider than 1/8 inch, multiple parallel cracks, or any crack that’s actively leaking. DIY repairs on significant structural damage often lead to more extensive and expensive problems later.

5. Algae Growth: The Green, Black, and Yellow Invaders

Algae growth is one of the most common and frustrating pool surface problems that pool owners face. These microscopic plants can quickly transform your crystal-clear water into a murky, uninviting mess if left unchecked.

Identifying Different Algae Types on Pool Surfaces

Green algae appears as a slimy coating that makes surfaces slippery and water cloudy. Black algae forms stubborn dark spots with deep roots that anchor to concrete and plaster surfaces. Yellow or mustard algae resembles pollen or sand and often clings to shaded areas, proving highly resistant to normal chlorine levels.

Comprehensive Algae Removal and Prevention Plans

For green algae, brush affected surfaces vigorously and shock your pool with chlorine at 2-3 times the normal dose. Black algae requires aggressive brushing with a stainless-steel brush followed by applying algaecide directly to spots. Yellow algae needs specialized treatments and higher chlorine levels. Maintain proper filtration, circulation, and chemical balance with weekly testing to prevent future algae invasions.

6. Rough Spots and Texture Issues: Comfort Concerns

Causes of Rough or Uneven Pool Surfaces

Rough spots on pool surfaces typically develop from chemical etching caused by improper pH balance. Excessive exposure to acidic conditions gradually erodes plaster and fiberglass surfaces, creating uncomfortable texture issues. Aging surfaces naturally become rougher over time, particularly with concrete pools. Poor initial installation or premature wearing of surface finishes also contributes to uneven textures that can scrape swimmers’ feet.

Smoothing Solutions and Maintenance Tips

For minor roughness, use specialized pool surface polishers or a pumice stone to gently buff affected areas. Acid washing can help restore moderately rough plaster surfaces but should be performed by professionals to prevent further damage. Maintaining proper chemical balance (pH 7.4-7.6) prevents future roughness, while adding a thin layer of plaster or applying epoxy coatings offers temporary solutions. For severely damaged surfaces, complete resurfacing provides the most effective long-term fix, though it’s the most expensive option.

7. Fading and Sun Damage: Time Takes Its Toll

Understanding UV Effects on Different Pool Surface Types

UV radiation doesn’t discriminate when attacking your pool surface. Vinyl liners typically show the most dramatic fading, with colors bleaching noticeably within 5-7 years of installation. Fiberglass surfaces develop a chalky appearance when sun-damaged, while even plaster and pebble finishes can lose their vibrancy over time. Darker surfaces show fading more quickly than lighter colors, especially in regions with intense year-round sunshine.

Restoring Color and Protecting Your Pool Surface

You can rejuvenate faded pool surfaces with specialized restoration products designed for your specific surface type. For vinyl liners, apply a vinyl protectant every 3 months during swimming season to prevent UV deterioration. Fiberglass pools benefit from an annual application of marine-grade wax or gel coat sealant. Consider installing an automatic pool cover that blocks 99% of UV rays when the pool isn’t in use. For severe cases, professional color restoration or complete resurfacing provides the most dramatic improvement in appearance.

Preventative Maintenance: Avoiding Future Pool Surface Problems

Your pool surface is a significant investment that deserves proper care. By addressing issues like scaling stains cracking etching and algae growth early you’ll extend the life of your pool surface and avoid costly repairs.

Remember that regular maintenance is your best defense against surface problems. Test your water chemistry weekly maintain proper pH and alkalinity levels and clean your pool thoroughly. Consider professional inspections at least once a year to catch potential issues before they escalate.

With the right knowledge and preventative approach you’ll enjoy your beautiful pool for years to come. When in doubt don’t hesitate to consult with a professional – their expertise can save you time money and frustration in the long run.

Frequently Asked Questions

What causes pool surface discoloration?

Pool surface discoloration typically stems from three main sources: organic stains (from leaves and algae), metal-based stains (rust, copper, or manganese), and chemical stains (from improper chlorine use or pH imbalances). Each type requires different treatment approaches, ranging from shock treatments for organic stains to specialized metal removers for metal-based discoloration. Always test treatments in a small area first before applying to the entire surface.

How can I remove calcium deposits from my pool surface?

Remove calcium deposits by using a pumice stone for small areas or specialized scale removal products for larger sections. Maintain proper pH (7.4-7.6) and calcium hardness levels (200-400 ppm) to prevent future buildup. Regular brushing helps prevent deposits from forming. For severe scaling, acid washing may be necessary, but consult a professional first to avoid damaging the pool surface.

Are hairline cracks in my pool surface serious?

Hairline cracks are typically cosmetic and don’t threaten structural integrity. They can be repaired with epoxy or polyurethane sealants. However, cracks wider than 1/8 inch, multiple parallel cracks, or actively leaking cracks indicate potential structural issues requiring professional assessment. Ignoring serious cracks can lead to water damage, leaks, and more extensive repair costs down the road.

How do I get rid of black algae in my pool?

Remove black algae by aggressively brushing affected areas with a stiff brush to break through its protective layer, then applying a targeted black algaecide directly to the spots. Superchlorinate the pool to 3-4 times the normal chlorine level. Maintain proper filtration and circulation, and run your filter continuously until the algae is eliminated. Prevention requires consistent chemical balance and regular brushing of the pool surface.

What causes rough spots on my pool surface?

Rough spots typically develop from chemical etching (caused by improper pH balance), aging surfaces, or improper installation. For minor roughness, use specialized pool surface polishers or pumice stones to smooth affected areas. Moderate roughness might require professional acid washing. Severe cases may need partial or complete resurfacing. Maintain proper chemical balance (pH 7.4-7.6) to prevent future roughness.

How often should pool surfaces be resurfaced?

Pool resurfacing intervals depend on the surface type: plaster surfaces typically last 7-10 years, exposed aggregate finishes 10-15 years, tile surfaces 15-20 years, and fiberglass shells 15-30 years. Signs you need resurfacing include widespread roughness, extensive staining that won’t respond to treatment, frequent algae problems despite proper chemistry, or structural cracks. Regular maintenance extends surface life significantly.

What causes etching on pool surfaces?

Etching occurs when acidic water dissolves the cement in plaster surfaces, creating rough, pitted areas. The primary cause is low pH levels (below 7.2), resulting from improper chemical balance or over-shocking the pool. Other factors include improperly dissolved chemicals coming in direct contact with surfaces or using acidic cleaning products. Maintain pH between 7.4-7.6 and alkalinity at 80-120 ppm to prevent etching.

How can I protect my pool surface from sun damage?

Protect your pool surface from UV damage by using an automatic pool cover when the pool isn’t in use, applying specialized UV protectants (particularly for vinyl and fiberglass surfaces), maintaining proper water chemistry to prevent chemical interactions that accelerate fading, and considering UV-resistant pool surface materials during installation or resurfacing. For vinyl liners, vinyl-specific conditioners can extend color life significantly.